Alastor Keychain vs Kitty Alastor: Which Hazbin Hotel Plush Wins?

Two Alastor keychains, two distinct personalities

If you're deciding between the Alastor Keychain and the Kitty Alastor Keychain, the choice comes down to which version of Alastor you want to carry. Both are 5-inch plush keychains made from minky fabric with felt accents and 100% PP cotton filling, but they offer very different looks. The standard Alastor Keychain shows him in his pink striped suit, while the Kitty Alastor Keychain turns him into a brown cat with pink hair and a long tail. Below, we break down the key differences to help you pick the one that fits your collection.

Design details that set them apart

• Alastor Keychain (5in): At 5 inches tall with a sharp yellow smile stretching over his face under deep red eyes as a thick fringe sweeps to the side, the black tips of his ears match the ends of the hair on either side of his face as a monocle rests on his right cheek and he wears an always dashing pink striped suit with short arms poking out from the sleeves. This is the classic Alastor look, faithful to his appearance in Hazbin Hotel, making it a natural pick for fans who want a recognizable character keychain.

  

• Kitty Alastor Keychain (5in): Standing at 5 inches tall with deep red eyes looking out over an evil yellow smile full of sharp teeth, as a monocle rests on his cheek, pointed ears poke out from the top of his pink hair that has black ends as a bowtie rests under his chin and pink paws hang to either side of his brown cat body with a long tail curling underneath. The Kitty Alastor is a playful reimagining, blending Alastor's features with a cat form. It's ideal if you prefer a more whimsical or unique take on the character.

  

Price and value: what you pay for each

At the time of writing, the standard Alastor Keychain is priced at $13.79, while the Kitty Alastor Keychain is $14.25. Both show a comparison price of $22.99, so you're saving on either option. The $0.46 difference is minor, so your decision should be based on design preference rather than cost. Keep in mind that prices can change, so check the current listings for the most up-to-date information.

Side-by-side: which keychain suits your style?

• Alastor Keychain (5in): Classic Alastor in pink striped suit; 5 inches tall; minky fabric with felt accents; 100% PP cotton; keyring attached with pink Youtooz tag; $13.79.
• Kitty Alastor Keychain (5in): Alastor as a brown cat with pink hair, bowtie, and long tail; 5 inches tall; minky fabric with felt accents; 100% PP cotton; keyring attached with pink tag; $14.25.

Display and care tips for your plush keychain

Both keychains are made from soft minky material, so they can pick up lint and dust. A gentle spot clean with a damp cloth is usually enough for surface dirt. Avoid machine washing or harsh chemicals, as these can damage the fabric and filling. When not attached to a bag, store them in a dust-free place to keep them looking fresh.

• Attach securely: Use the included keyring to clip the plush to your backpack, purse, or belt loop. The keyring is attached by a pink tag; ensure it's fastened tightly to avoid losing your keychain.
• Rotate your display: To prevent excessive wear, alternate between keychains or move them to different bags. This also lets you enjoy both designs if you collect both.
• Keep away from rough surfaces: The felt accents and minky fabric can snag on Velcro or rough textures. Be mindful of where you hang your keychain to avoid pulls.

Making your final choice

If you want a recognizable Alastor that matches his on-screen appearance, the standard Alastor Keychain is the obvious pick. If you love creative twists or cat-themed collectibles, the Kitty Alastor Keychain offers a fun alternative. Both are well-made from soft materials and come at a similar price point, so you can't go wrong either way. Consider which design makes you smile more—after all, that's what collecting is about.